Skip to Content
Industrial Ethernet switch

Siemens SCALANCE X and Solidot SW4 industrial-switch comparison

Compare SCALANCE X-000/X-200 and Solidot SW4 switches by ports, speed, PROFINET traffic priority, management, rings, power and environment.

Short answer

What does this page recommend?

A technical alternative, not a drop-in substitute

The Solidot SW4 family includes unmanaged, PROFINET-traffic-priority and managed options. MRP/RSTP, PROFINET conformance, SNMP, VLAN, cybersecurity or certifications of a SCALANCE model must not be assumed equal.

Solidot

ProControl products to evaluate first

The exact configuration is selected after engineering review.

SW4-GUP05D-PN
Solidot

SW4-GUP05D-PN

5×Gigabit RJ45; IEEE 802.1p priority for PROFINET EtherType 0x8892 traffic

Open technical page
SW4-GMSP8D-SFP2
Solidot

SW4-GMSP8D-SFP2

Separate model for projects needing management and fibre uplinks

Open technical page
Technical comparison

Similar requirement, different architecture

The table explains product architectures; it is not an exact order-code selection.

Validation areaSiemens SCALANCE X-000 / X-200Solidot / ProControl candidate
Switch classX-000 is unmanaged; functions vary by model in the managed X-200 family.SW4-GUP/HUP are unmanaged, GUP-PN is traffic-priority, and GMP/GMS are managed options.
Ports and performanceRJ45/M12/SFP, 100 Mbit/Gigabit, switching capacity and latency depend on exact model.SW4-GUP05D-PN publishes 5×Gigabit RJ45, up to 7 µs forwarding latency and dual power.
PROFINETConformance, LLDP/DCP, diagnostics and MRP are selected by exact model.IEEE 802.1p priority does not imply PROFINET certification or equal conformance class.
Management and ringsVLAN, SNMP, RSTP/MRP, rings and diagnostics depend on X-200 order code.For VLAN, SNMP, RSTP/MSTP/ERPS/MRP or redundancy, prove the exact managed SW4 code separately.
Industrial conditionsRedundant supply, alarm, EMC, temperature and certifications vary by model.GUP05D-PN publishes -40…+80 °C and IP40; map all environmental, EMC and certification requirements from datasheets.
Suitable scenario

When is it worth evaluating?

  • New unmanaged or basic PROFINET machine networks
  • Topologies with clear port and environmental requirements
  • Projects where management and ring functions can be redesigned
Migration gate

Before making a decision

  1. List the exact SCALANCE model and every used function.
  2. Fix port, speed, fibre, PoE and connector requirements.
  3. Document MRP/RSTP, VLAN, SNMP, LLDP/DCP and diagnostics.
  4. Verify temperature, redundant supply, alarm and EMC class.
  5. Test load, ring break, broadcast and power interruption.
Frequently asked

Clear answers about alternatives and migration

Is this a drop-in replacement?

No. It is not a direct substitute until exact model, electrical, protocol-role, mechanical, software and certification checks pass.

What should I provide for selection?

The exact existing code, diagram or I/O list, PLC/network data, supply, environment and special functions in use.

Is SW4-GUP05D-PN PROFINET certified?

The current official record publishes PROFINET traffic priority; do not call it certified without a certificate or conformance document.

This content compares manufacturer-published data under the same project requirement; it does not guarantee direct substitution or project compatibility. ProControl engineering must validate exact model, revision, protocol, electrical, safety and environmental conditions.

Validate the match with an engineer

Share the exact existing code, I/O list, network and environment so we can identify the right solution without assumptions.

Talk to ProControl